I received this book from TLC Book Tours in exchange for my review.
Even though I know a lot about Judaism, I had a hard time determining what mythology in this book was real and what was made up. I felt like I needed a bit more background on the various myths explored in the book, including that of the White Rebbe and the customs of the Berukhim Hasidim – who do not actually exist. There were two things that stood out as that which true religious Jews would not have done and I imagine the author could excuse those things as customs of her made up sect. I do wonder if the author just didn’t realize the customs of religious Judaism in regards to those things. At the same time, I found myself confused by the mythology in the book and wanting to know more as a reader and as a Jewish reader specifically.
If the book is regarded as fully fictional and somewhat fantasy, there are many enjoyable things about it, especially the tie-ins from the past to the present. Coincidentally, Marjorie and Holly’s grandfather told them stories that are very familiar to Holly’s husband, a member of the Berukhim Hasidim. Marjorie uncovers information about her past and Holly’s present as she does her research on the White Rebbe and the Angel of Losses.
There is a lot in this book and it is deep with meaning. It reminded me of something one might read for a college class. I feel like it is the kind of book that can be discussed – maybe a great one for a book group! It is not an easy read, but an interesting one for sure.
